Ahh, September in the Gulf of Mexico. The crowds of the summer months have begun to depart, and the snowbirds won't arrive for a couple of months. September, the start of the autumn shoulder season in Florida, is one of the best times of the year to visit Anna Maria Island (AMI). Due in part to its comfortable climate, fewer crowds, and a wide array of things to do, an Anna Maria Island getaway in September is always a good idea.
September Weather on Anna Maria Island
Photo Credit: Mark Winfrey
The fall weather on AMI in September is some of the best year-round. With average temperatures ranging from the mid-70s to the high 80s, the weather is perfect for enjoying the many outdoor activities Anna Maria Island has to offer (with much less sweat)!
You'll find that the island is still enjoying the warmth of summer but with slightly cooler temperatures in the evenings. While there might be an occasional chance of rain and more precipitation than the winter months, the showers are typically brief and followed by clear skies, offering a nice break from the sun.
Although humidity is still a factor, it's generally less than in the summer months, making beach days and other outdoor activities perfectly comfortable.
Best Fall Activities on Anna Maria Island
1. Have a Peaceful Beach Day
Photo Credit: Ken Schulze
The beaches in September are simply idyllic. With fewer crowds than in the throes of summer, you'll have more space to enjoy the soft white sands and sparkling turquoise waters. Popular spots include Bean Point, known for its secluded nature and gorgeous sunsets, or Coquina Beach if you're looking for something with more amenities, such as picnic areas and playgrounds.
Photo Credit: Mark Winfrey
Be sure to take advantage of the perfect weather and get out on the water with all the different watersport rentals available on island.
AMI is the perfect place with generally safe and gentle waters to try out paddleboarding, kayaking, or even jet skiing. AMI Paddleboard and Kayak Adventures has a great selection of rentals available!
For nature enthusiasts, the Robinson Preserve is a popular place to visit This 600+ acre nature preserve offers miles of trails for hiking, biking, and birdwatching. You can also kayak through the mangrove channels or climb up the observation tower for sweeping views of Tampa Bay. Leffis Key is another popular nature reserve.
For something even further off the beaten path, try Perico Preserve or Palma Sola Botanical Park!
Photo Credit: Smiltena
Fishing in September is a great option as well, with plenty of opportunities to catch fish like snook, redfish, and tarpon. Local charters such as Island Discount Tackle can take you to the best spots that only the locals know about. If you don't want to take a boat out, the piers at Rod & Reel Pier and Anna Maria City Pier are great for casting a line off the dock.
Photo Credit: Nick Harding
Explore the local culture at the Anna Maria Island farmers markets. These markets generally have a great selection of fresh produce, handmade crafts, fresh seafood, and other yummy local foods. The markets typically operate on weekends, making them a perfect trip for a Saturday or Sunday morning. Some of our favorite fall markets include:
Photo Credit: bbernard
AMI's nightlife is laidback, friendly, and great for a fun night out. The after-dark scene features some of best bars on island where you'll likely find locals waxing poetic about island life.
Depending on your tastes, there are plenty of options, from beachside bars with live music to cozy pubs where the locals hang out. For a low key option with the best cocktails on the island, try The Doctor's Office. For something more lively with live music and perhaps even some dancing, The Ugly Grouper in Holmes Beach is a popular spot!
Photo Credit: Studio Romantic
For those seeking a bit of relaxation and pampering, the island has a number of spas offering a myriad of treatments. The Sea-renity Beach Spa & Eco Boutique in Bradenton Beach offers seaside massages and holistic treatments right on the shore. If you want to stay indoors, Body & Sol Spa and Wellness offers a range of services, from massages to yoga classes. These wellness centers provide the perfect escape to rejuvenate your mind and body.
Photo Credit: Rhea Newman
Exploring the island's shops is another good option for September on AMI, particularly during those afternoon showers. Pine Avenue in Anna Maria is the go-to spot for boutique shopping. You'll find plenty of interesting items here, from handcrafted jewelry to island-inspired home décor. Pop into shops like Pink & Navy Boutique and Shiny Fish Emporium for unique clothing and souvenirs.
Photo Credit: Anna Maria Golf Carts
Anna Maria Island is divided into three different towns: Anna Maria, Holmes Beach, and Bradenton Beach. Each area has its own unique personality and things to do. Bradenton Beach offers a lively atmosphere with historic Bridge Street, bustling shops, and energetic nightlife. Holmes Beach is centrally located and has a wide variety of dining and shopping options, making it a convenient place for visitors to stay. In Anna Maria, you'll find a more laid-back vibe with fewer crowds.
Pro Tip: Rent a golf cart for a fun way to explore the island!
Fall Events on Anna Maria Island
Photo Credit: FRANK SOLORZANO
Although the crowds may slow down in Anna Maria Island during the fall, the seasonal events don't! These events are the perfect date night out during your getaway.
- Bayfest: This is the island's biggest and longest running annual event! You'll experience live music, local crafts, and a classic car show. (Mid October)
- Hunsader Farms Pumpkin Festival: This annual event over the Anna Maria Island Bridge in Bradenton is the perfect family outing which includes live music, games, train rides, and a butterfly experience. (October)
- Symphony on the Sand: Head to Coquina Beach for a harmonious blend of food and music. (Early November)
September on Anna Maria Island: Packing Must-Haves
Photo Credit: Art_Photo
Packing for a September trip to Anna Maria Island should include lightweight, breathable clothing for the high temperatures during the day and a light jacket or coverup for the low temperatures in the evenings. Layers are key! Other things to consider:
- Don't forget your swimwear, biodegradable sunscreen, and a hat for beach days.
- A good pair of walking shoes is necessary for exploring the hiking trails and nature preserves.
- If you plan on spending time in the nature parks, also pack some bug spray.
- Given the possibility of afternoon showers, it's also a good idea to bring a rain jacket or umbrella.
Is September a Good Time to Visit Anna Maria Island?
Absolutely! To be fair, there's never a bad time to visit AMI. With average highs in the 80s and cool, comfortable evenings, the weather is similar to the spring months. The gorgeous weather and fewer crowds make for a leisurely, comfortable vacation.
If you haven't booked your accommodation yet, get in touch with us at Anna Maria Island Beach Rentals. Our vacation rental properties are located all over the island, so you'll be able to stay nearby.
