Posted on 11/6/2023

6 Tastiest Bakeries on Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island, known for its breathtaking beaches and quaint small town ambiance, also hides another delightful secret: its bakeries. As the sun rises over the pristine coastline, the aroma of freshly baked pastries fills the air, promising a tantalizing treat to start the day.

From classic croissants to innovative island-inspired desserts and fresh-baked bread, the bakeries here are nothing short of sweet home baked delights. Pair any of them with a stop at one of AMI's excellent coffee shops, and breakfast is well on its way!

In this guide, we'll take you through the crème de la crème of the island's bakery scene that you can't miss when staying at an Anna Maria Island vacation home.

Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery

Photo Credit: roman tohtohunov

  • Address: 9801 Gulf Dr, Anna Maria, FL
  • What to Order: Cinnamon Rolls or William Dean truffles

Nestled in the heart of AMI is the family-owned Anna Maria Island Creamery & Bakery, a haven for those with a penchant for sweet indulgence, whether ice cream or baked goods. This isn't just any bakery; it's a celebration of authentic Italian craftsmanship. From their handmade Italian Gelato and refreshing Sorbettos to their array of meticulously crafted pastries, every item is worth a taste.

As you step inside, the aroma of freshly baked Danishes and croissants fills the air, but what truly sets them apart is their exclusive offering of William Dean truffles.

These truffles aren't just chocolates; they're cinematic sensations, having graced the silver screen in the Hunger Games. Recognized among the world's finest chocolatiers, William Dean is renowned for its innovative flavor combinations, such as the delightful port & fig and the nostalgic peanut butter jelly.

Anna Maria Bake House

Photo Credit: OlgaBombologna

  • Address: 10101 Gulf Drive, Anna Maria, FL
  • What to Order: Bourbon Pecan Pie

Founded in 2015, the Anna Maria Bake House has deep roots, starting its journey at the renowned Sandbar restaurant. What began as an initiative to replace store-bought bread with in-house creations has now blossomed into a full-fledged bakery in Downtown Anna Maria that caters not only to the Sandbar restaurant but also to other AMI restaurants as well as the vibrant farmer's market at Gamble Creek Farms.

Committed to quality and authenticity, Anna Maria Bake House takes pride in sourcing the finest ingredients. From rustic breads to decadent desserts, both savory and sweet, every creation blends tradition and innovation.

Key to their philosophy is the emphasis on natural and wholesome ingredients. Every bread, every pastry, is devoid of additives and preservatives, ensuring that what you consume is as genuine as it gets.

This commitment to purity is reflected not just in their ingredients but also in their process. Before the sun even comes up, the dedicated bakery staff is already working hard, ensuring that freshly baked goods are ready to grace the tables of the restaurants and the homes of those who opt for pick-up and delivery.

Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe

Photo Credit: viennetta

  • Address: 3324 E. Bay Drive, Holmes Beach, FL
  • What to Order: Key Lime Pie Cheesecake, obviously!

At the heart of Anna Maria Island's bakery scene lies the gem, Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe. As soon as you step inside, you're greeted by the irresistible aroma of baked goods crafted with passion and precision. They pride themselves on using the finest local ingredients, ensuring every bite is a testament to quality and taste. Their signature cheesecakes, whimsically named "Scuties", and the delightful "CharCUTIErie" boxes are perfect for beach days, special events, or simply to express appreciation to someone dear.

Every item feels handcrafted with immense love. But they're not just about sweets. The cafe also boasts a diverse menu that includes delectable breakfast offerings, with homemade bagels and muffins stealing the show, as well as savory flatbreads and rich brownies. Whether you're a local or a visitor, Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe is definitely worth a stop as one of the best bakeries on Anna Maria Island!

Bolo's Baked Goods

Photo Credit: Matt Antonino

  • Address: 415 Pine Ave, Anna Maria, FL
  • What to Order: Double Chocolate Chunk Cookies

At Bolo's Baked Goods on Anna Maria Island, simplicity and quality go hand in hand. This local bakery takes home baking to the next level, offering goods that are freshly made to order by experienced chefs.

Bolo's is particularly known for its cookies and rice crispy style treats. And while they've perfected the classics, they also enjoy mixing things up by introducing new flavors regularly. Think Iced Oatmeal or Espresso Cookies and Smore's Crispy Treats.

Another notable feature of Bolo's is its delivery service. Whether you're right around the corner on Anna Maria Island or located across the country, Bolo's ensures that you can enjoy their baked goods by delivery.

Mademoiselle Paris French Restaurant & Bakery

Photo Credit: Arkadiusz Fajer

  • Address: 9906 Gulf Dr, Anna Maria, FL
  • What to Order: Fresh Fruit Tart

From the moment you step into Mademoiselle Paris on Gulf Drive, a wave of enchanting aromas of freshly baked bread and traditional French pastries greets you, transporting you straight to the boulevards of Paris. It's not just about the pastries; it's about experiencing the authentic essence of French culinary artistry.

At Mademoiselle Paris, the commitment is simple: offer guests an unmatched tasting experience. Every bite, whether it's a flaky croissant or a sumptuous éclair, is a testament to the use of premium quality ingredients and the meticulous craftsmanship and classical French training that goes into creating these gourmet delights.

But the offerings don't end there. Alongside, their extensive menu boasts everything from custom cakes to the perfect baguette and beyond. They even offer full breakfast, lunch, and dinner (on Friday and Saturday nights) along with an extensive wine and cocktail list.

Whether you're seeking the perfect pastry to accompany your morning coffee or a custom cake to make an occasion even more special, Mademoiselle Paris is your go-to bakery on AMI for a French experience!

Ginny's & Jane E's Cafe and Gift Store

Photo Credit: Na_Zarr

  • Address: 9807 Gulf Dr, Anna Maria, FL 34216
  • What to Order: Apricot Cream Cheese Scone

A local favorite on Anna Maria Island, Ginny's & Jane E's Cafe and Gift Store is more than just a cafe. As you step inside the cafe located in the "Old Florida" neighborhood on the north side of the island, you're met with the delightful aroma of fresh baked goods that perfectly complement the ambiance of the cafe.

For those on-the-go, or perhaps just in need of a quick, delicious pick-me-up, the in-house bakery is the place to be. Indulge in a sinfully rich Cinnamon Bun or savor the subtle sweetness of a freshly baked muffin or scone. And if your sweet tooth is calling out for more, the assortment of pies and cakes promises to satisfy!

The bakery, while rooted in Jane's classic recipes, has evolved to cater to the diverse tastes of today. With the inclusion of vegan treats and options that are gluten-free and dairy-free, there's truly something for everyone.

Trying the Best Bakeries on Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island is not just a destination for sun and surf; it's a culinary treasure trove for those with a sweet tooth. From the authentic French pastries of Mademoiselle Paris to the artisanal creations at Anna Maria Bake House, there's a bakery delight for every palate.

Whether you're seeking a traditional cupcake or open to something uniquely local like Bolo's rice crispy-style delights, AMI's bakeries promise both satisfaction and surprise. So, on your next visit, take a moment to indulge in these handcrafted baked goods. After all, every memorable trip deserves an equally memorable treat.

Book your Anna Maria Island beach home rental today!

Previous A Visitor's Guide to Winter on Anna Maria Island 7 Best Italian Restaurants on Anna Maria Island Next