Posted on 11/21/2023

Deep Sea Fishing Guide to Anna Maria Island

Welcome to Anna Maria Island, a pristine paradise nestled off the Gulf coast of Florida, where the azure waves beckon fishing aficionados from all corners of the world. Whether you're waking up to the sound of the sea in one of our charming vacation rental homes or contemplating a visit, you're in for an aquatic treat.

IWhile Anna Maria Island boasts a number of fishing opportunities, this guide zeroes in on the unparalleled thrill of deep sea fishing. We'll explore the wonders of deep sea fishing, from the different species you can reel in to the seasoned charters waiting to guide your journey.

So, grab your fishing gear, let your excitement build, and let's embark on this deep sea adventure together!

What You'll Reel in Deep Sea Fishing in AMI

Anna Maria Island's deep waters promise an adventure and a diverse array of marine species waiting to be reeled in. Each fish species offers its own unique challenge, ensuring that no two fishing trips are alike. Here's a glimpse into the underwater treasures you can hope to encounter.

Remember, the kind of fish you catch can often vary based on the season, water temperature, and your specific location. It's always a good idea to check with local charters or fishing forecasts to know what's biting during your visit. Whether you're aiming for a specific species or just looking to be surprised, Anna Maria Island's waters are sure to offer a thrilling fishing experience.

King Mackerel (Kingfish)

Photo Credit: Phuketian.S

Known for their sheer speed and agility, hooking a king mackerel is every angler's dream. With their shimmering silver bodies and razor-sharp teeth, they are a prize worth boasting about. Available primarily during the warmer months, they often swim in schools, making them a frequent catch.


Photo Credit: Fabien Monteil

These bottom-dwelling giants are a challenge to reel in, given their strength and tenacity. Found around reefs and underwater structures, groupers come in various species, including the popular red grouper and gag grouper.


Photo Credit: Fabien Monteil

Another popular catch around Anna Maria Island, snappers are recognized by their vibrant red hue and delicious taste. While they can be found year-round, summer is the peak season for these beauties.


Photo Credit: Daniel Y Smith

Often referred to as the "Silver King," tarpon are one of the most sought-after game fish. Their acrobatic jumps and sheer strength make them a formidable opponent for even the most experienced anglers.


Photo Credit: Okyela

While not as common as the others, the sailfish is a prized catch for its majestic appearance and speed. Its long, slender body and characteristic sail-like dorsal fin are sights to behold.


Photo Credit: lunamarina

Venturing further offshore might reward you with a powerful tuna at the end of your line. These deep-sea dwellers are known for their speed and strength, making them a challenging but rewarding catch.

Anna Maria Island Deep Sea Fishing Charters

There are plenty of fishing charter companies to choose from in AMI. These are the best options for deep sea fishing tours!

AMI Charters

Photo Credit: AMI Charters

At AMI Charters, the spotlight is always on providing a personalized experience tailored to your desires. Be it a young one's exhilarating first catch, a seasoned angler taking on a tarpon with a fly, or a family outing to a hidden island haven, the central theme remains - prioritizing YOU.

AMI Charters resonate with the value of hard-earned money and the anticipation of a memorable vacation. Beyond the captivating views and thrilling catches, what their captains treasure most are your smiles and contentment. Rest assured, their boats are immaculately kept, fishing gear is top-notch, and every captain is expertly trained, licensed, and insured. With AMI Charters, all you're tasked with is having a good time.

Just Kickin Back Charters

Photo Credit: Ben Harness

  • Address: 101 S. Bay Street, Suite 1782, Anna Maria, FL
  • Website:

Situated on Anna Maria Island, Just Kickin' Back Charters specializes in offshore fishing, offering a chance to reel in a variety of fish from Key West Grunts to Giant Goliath Groupers. A unique edge they hold is their Federal Permit, allowing them to fish legally beyond the standard 9-mile limit and granting anglers access to deeper and richer fishing grounds.

With their main base on Holmes Beach and multiple pick-up points around the island, they cater to anglers of all skill levels. Whether you're looking for a brief 4-hour trip or an extensive 12-hour full day expedition, Captain Philip ensures a memorable experience tailored to every guest's needs.

Captain Mike's Anna Maria Island Boat Tours and Fishing Charters

With 40 years of expertise navigating the waters of Anna Maria Island, Tampa Bay, and Sarasota, Captain Mike Greig is your go-to for both inshore fishing and nearshore fishing adventures in Holmes Beach.

Captain Mike knows precisely where to take you, whether you're angling for snook, redfish, trout, and flounder in the bay or aiming for grouper, snapper, kingfish, and more in the gulf. Anna Maria's summers boast some of Florida's finest tarpon fishing, with both day and evening trips on offer. Early reservations are a good idea, given the popularity.

Families with children are warmly welcomed, and all essentials, including fishing licenses, ice, bait, and tackle, are conveniently provided. Whether it's an exhilarating day offshore or a half-day escapade inshore, Capt. Mike promises a fishing experience like no other.

DIY vs. Hiring a Company

While there are a number of reasons you might want to head out on your own instead of hiring a fishing charter, there are a few factors you must consider first.

  • Equipment: Do you have the right fishing gear, or will you need to rent or buy? Consider the costs and the quality of the equipment available for rent.
  • Knowledge: The waters around Anna Maria Island are teeming with fish, but knowing where and when to fish can make a significant difference. Without local knowledge, you might miss out on prime spots.
  • Safety: Navigating unfamiliar waters can be tricky. Ensure you're aware of local tides, currents, and weather conditions.

The Benefits of Hiring a Charter

Opting for a boat tour or professional charter offers a hassle-free, enriching experience. Expert guidance makes you more likely to have a fruitful day on the water.

  • Expertise: Captains of local charters know the waters like the back of their hand. They'll take you to the best fishing spots and give you tips on technique.
  • Convenience: Everything you need for a successful fishing trip is provided, from top-notch gear to bait and even licenses. Just show up and enjoy!
  • Safety: Professional charters prioritize your safety. With experienced captains and well-maintained boats, you're in good hands.

While the thrill of DIY fishing has its appeal, hiring a charter on Anna Maria Island promises a more relaxed, productive, and enlightening experience. Whether you're a novice or a seasoned angler, consider what you want most from the trip and choose accordingly.

Head Out Deep Sea Fishing on Anna Maria Island

With its azure saltwater and abundant marine life, Anna Maria Island stands as an angler's dream. Whether you're drawn to the allure of a great day catching the big one offshore or simply yearning for a tranquil day surrounded by nature, AMI promises a deep-sea fishing experience like no other.

As you consider your options, remember the shared goal: the joy of fishing, the thrill of the catch, and the unforgettable memories crafted amidst the sea's vast expanse. So, pack your gear and sunscreen, gather your enthusiasm, and set sail for an unmatched deep-sea adventure on Anna Maria Island!

Book your Anna Maria beach rental today!

Previous 7 Best Italian Restaurants on Anna Maria Island Ringing in the New Year on Anna Maria Island Next